Kendall Jackson Pinot Noir vs MacMurray vs Halleck Vineyard (Wine Review)

Kendall Jackson Pinot Noir MacMurray Halleck Vineyard
Kendall Jackson Vintner's Reserve Pinot Noir vs MacMurray Estate Pinot Noir vs Halleck Vineyard Russian River Pinot Noir

We’re in Sonoma wine tasting and talking about Kendall Jackson Pinot Noir, MacMurray Estate, and Halleck Vineyard Russian River Valley Pinot Noir.

Read on to find out which of these New World Pinots are best for picnics, parties, porches, and anything by candlelight. 

Kendall Jackson Pinot Noir Wine Tasting Notes

Kendall Jackson Vintner's Reverse Pinot Noir is the most famous of all their variants.
Kendall Jackson Vintner’s Reverse Pinot Noir is the most famous of all their variants.

Because Kendall-Jackson is a major player on the world stage and a defining fixture of the California AVA with vineyards spread over more than 5000 yards along the Sonoma Coast, we actually didn’t want to like this red wine. We typically cheer for the underdog instead. Nonetheless, the deep-but-clear garnet coloring is the hallmark of a brilliantly crafted Kendall Jackson Pinot Noir, which is the most famous of all their variants.

After the first glance, we were prepared to be captivated. Kendall Jackson didn’t disappoint. Midsummer red raspberry and bright cherry fruit notes dance with sultry earthy notes infused with cola and mild spice accents in true Pinot fashion. We loved how this red wine’s taste was true to the promise delivered in its nose. We felt transported to the middle of a field filled with ripe raspberries on a warm summer day. The whispers of vanilla in its subtly soft finish brought an elegantly grand finale to this vintner’s reserve varietal. 

  • Vintage: 2019
  • AVA: California, California
  • Alcohol: 14.5%
  • Retail Price: $14 
  • Restaurant Price: Approximately $35
  • Pairings: Perfect with a quality burger or lamb dish


MacMurray Estate Wine Tasting Notes

MacMurray Pinot Noir from the Central Coast is a pleasantly fruity picnic and porch wine.
MacMurray Pinot Noir from the Central Coast is a pleasantly fruity picnic and porch wine.

This opulent Pinot from Central Coast AVA offers a nearly translucent, dark jewel tone with just a hint of haze. Its fruity bouquet is laced with lavender fields, dark cherries, blackberries, and pomegranate, ending with the trademark hints of vanilla, signifying a traditionally crafted Pinot Noir that deviates sharply from the Kendall Jackson Pinot Noir’s berry pie notes.

MacMurray is an excellent choice for those who like their red a little on the sweet side. We even detected notes of hard candy swimming under its surface along with a contrasting small dash of freshly cracked black pepper. 

Overall, this fruity wine is an average, perfectly pleasant option that is well-suited as a picnic or cocktail wine. We also think it’s great on its own as a pre-dinner wine. Or sip it on the porch on a hot afternoon with a bowl of fresh fruit. 

  • Vintage: 2019
  • AVA: Central Coast, CA
  • Alcohol: 13.9%
  • Retail price: $26
  • Restaurant Price: $65
  • Pairing: Pair it with pork or casual al fresco fare

Halleck Vineyard Three Sons Wine Tasting Notes

Halleck Vineyard Three Sons Cuvee Pinot Noir from the Russian River Valley
Halleck Vineyard Three Sons Cuvee Pinot Noir from the Russian River Valley brings classic elegance to any occasion. 

The most expensive of our three options, we consequently expected more from this varietal — and it delivered. The crystal clear clarity was the first clue that we were in for a classic Russian River Valley Pinot Noir experience. This wine also delivered that elusive spark of artistry rarely captured by large commercial wineries. 

The nose was bright with light red cherries mingling seamlessly with notes of earth and forest floor. There’s also a gentle touch of warm cloves and cinnamon. We were particularly impressed with how this extremely well-balanced red delivered that extra pop of acidity that’s essential for superb pairings.

  • Vintage: 2018
  • AVA: Russian River Valley, California 
  • Retail Price: $55
  • Restaurant Price: Approximately $137
  • Pairing: Pair it with Filet Mignon prepared with Porcini mushrooms and served with tarragon butter

Wine Tasting Video

Ross Halleck and Harris Miner in Sonoma Wine Tasting and Reviewing 3 New World Pinots.

Pinot Wrap Up

Each of these wines has a place on the dinner table, in the picnic basket, or at a cocktail party. We recommend:

  1. MacMurray Estate Pinot Noir 2019 under the sun
  2. Halleck Vineyard Three Sons Pinot Noir 2018 by candlelight
  3. Kendall-Jackson Vintner’s Reserve Pinot Noir 2019 for dressing up a burger or a casual pasta night. 

In closing, we feel like the Halleck Vineyard’s Pinot Noir option brings boutique winery artistry to the table in a tangible way. There are a large number of lovely New World Pinot Noirs on today’s market. But this is the one to uncork when the occasion calls for something out of the ordinary.

If you’d like to try it, we invite you to join us for an intimate Sonoma wine tasting in Sebastopol at our estate. Our shop our selection of some of the Best California Pinot Noir.

Follow Us

Marta Heacock

Marta Heacock

Marta spends her time between her home on the West Coast and a salmon cannery on the southern tip of Alaska’s panhandle that she co-owns with her son. She frequently brings these worlds together by pairing wild Alaska salmon with Pinot Noir.

Belle Glos Las Alturas 2019 and Halleck Vineyard Haas Vineyard 2018 are exceptional Pinot Noirs, with very different profiles.

Belle Glos Pinot Noir Las Alturas vs Halleck Vineyard Haas Pinot Noir (Wine Review)

We’re in Sonoma wine tasting and reviewing the Belle Glos Las Alturas 2019 and our own Halleck Vineyard Haas Vineyard 2018.  These are two of…

Read More...
Halleck Vineyard Estate Grown and Kosta Brown Pinot Noir from Sonoma, California

Kosta Browne Pinot Noir vs Halleck Vineyard (Wine Review)

In this post, Ross Halleck and Harris Miner are wine tasting in Sonoma and reviewing two of the best California Pinot Noir wines from the…

Read More...
Cherry Pie, O. Cyrot Bourgogne and Halleck Vineyard Hillside Cuvee Pinot Noirs

Cherry Pie Pinot Noir vs Bourgogne vs Halleck Vineyard (Wine Review)

In this review, we’re in Sonoma wine tasting and comparing a blended California Pinot Noir, a French Burgundy and our own Hillside Sonoma Coast Pinot…

Read More...